The Greatest Baseball Team Ever Assembled
March 6th, 2010 | by adamburnett |General Manager
Branch Rickey 1913-1955 Browns/Cardinals/Dodgers/Pirates
Signed Jackie Robinson and drafted Roberto Clemente, played a major part in developing frame work the Minor League Farm System, introduced the batting helmet. Won 4 World Series with the “Gashouse Gang”.
Honorable Mention
John Schuerholz 1981-2007
Architect of Royals and Braves championship runs. Won 15 division titles in free agency era.
Manager
John McGraw 1899-1932 Baltimore Orioles/New York Giants
2763-1948 with a .586 W-L% 11 Pennants 3 World Series Titles
Honorable Mention
Joe McCarthy 1926-1950
2125-1333 .615 W-L% best in the history of baseball
Cubs/Yankees/Red Sox 9 Pennants 7 World Series titles
Bobby Cox 1978-1985, 1990-2010 Braves/Blue Jays
2413-1930 .556 W-L% 14 consecutive division championships, 5 Pennants, 1 World Series title
Catcher
Johnny Bench 1967-1983 Reds
2-time NL MVP by the age of 25, won 10 consecutive Gold Gloves
Honorable Mention
Josh Gibson never played in MLB, but his legend is too intriguing to not take into consideration.
First Base
Lou Gehrig 1923-1939 Yankees
8 seasons with more than 200 hits, 4 seasons with more than 165 RBI’s. 13 seasons with an OPS over 1.000
Honorable Mention
Albert Pujols 2001-present day Cardinals
The greatest hitter I’ve watched in person. On pace to surpass many of the all-time greats. With every player of the current era, you have to wonder if his numbers are tainted as well. Unfortunately, it’s a case of guilt by association.
Second Base
Rogers Hornsby 1915-1937 Cardinals/Cubs/Giants/Braves/Browns
3 seasons with over a .400 batting average, 7 batting titles, led league in RBI 4 times.
Honorable Mention
Jackie Robinson 1947-1956 Dodgers played only 10 seasons, but one of the first run producers from the position
Shortstop
Honus Wagner 1897-1917 Pirates/Colonels
”The Flying Dutchman” won 8 NL batting titles, led the league in slugging 6 times, and stolen bases 5 times.
Honorable Mention
Ernie Banks 1953-1971 Cubs 4 consecutive seasons of 40 plus homers won back to back MVP’s.
Third Base
Michael Jack Schmidt 1972-1989 Phillies
13 seasons with 30 plus homers. Led the NL in homers 8 times. 3-time NL MVP
Honorable Mention
Eddie Mathews 1952-1968 Braves/Astros/Tigers 512 HR 1487 SO 1444 BB show power with good plate discipline.
Outfielders
Hank Aaron 1954-1976 Braves/Brewers
Subtract the 755 HR and he still had 3016 hits. 1402 BB to 1383 SO in his career. 6856 total bases and 2297 RBI both most in history of baseball.
Willie Mays 1951-1973 Giants/Mets
Mays hit 660 HR playing in cavernous pitchers parks. What would Willie Mays do if he played in some of the launching pads of today? Mays is the greatest defensive outfielder in the history of the game.
Ted Williams 1939-1960 Red Sox
“Splendid Splinter” Is 8th all-time in avg, 1st in OBP, 2nd in SLG, 2nd in OPS. What would the numbers be if he didn’t miss time due to military service? I also own a Sears Ted Williams Fishing Rod that I was my grandfathers.
Honorable Mention
Mickey Mantle 1951-1968 Yankees
3-time MVP won AL Triple Crown in 1956. 536 HR as the greatest switch hitter that ever lived.
Joe DiMaggio 1936-1951 Yankees
In 12 of his 13 seasons the Yankee Clipper had more walks than strikeouts, while in 7 of the 13 seasons he had more HR than strikeouts.
Ty Cobb 1905-1928 Tigers/Athletics
4189 career hits, highest career batting average in the history of baseball at.366, won 11 batting titles.
Designated Hitter
Babe Ruth 1914-1935 Red Sox/Yankees/Braves
In today’s game Ruth probably wouldn’t have seen the field much. You find a way to squeeze in a guy with 714 HR, 2213 RBI and a career OBP of .474
Starting Pitchers
Cy Young 1890-1911 Spiders/Americans/Naps/Perfectos/Cardinals
the award is named after him, how could he not be on the list? 22 seasons with a 2.63 career ERA. 511 career wins and his other pitching records will never be broken. Adjusted ERA 138
Walter Johnson 1907-1927 Senators
Won 417 games with a career 2.17 ERA. From 1910-1916 didn’t post an ERA over 2.00. 2-time MVP, Adjusted ERA 147
Randy Johnson 1988-2009 Expos/Mariners/Astros/D-backs/Yankees/Giants
303 career wins. 5 Cy Young Awards. Adjusted ERA 136. 10.6098 SO per 9 IP highest in the history of baseball
Lefty Grove 1925-1941 Athletics/Red Sox
300 Wins with a career 3.06 ERA. Adjusted ERA 148 2nd highest in history of baseball
Greg Maddux 1986-2008 Cubs/Braves/Padres/Dodgers
“The Surgeon” won 355 games in the steroid era of baseball to go along with the trend of building launching pad ball parks. His 1992-1998 performance didn’t have a WHIP higher than 1.049 with his highest ERA during that stretch coming in a 2.72. Won 4 consecutive Cy Young awards and 18 Gold Gloves, Adjusted ERA 132
Honorable Mention
Pedro Martinez 1992-2009 Dodgers/Expos/Red Sox/Mets/Phillies
3 Cy Young Awards Career 2.93 ERA and .687 Winning Percentage Adjusted ERA 154 highest in the history of baseball, 1.0398 SO per 9 IP 3rd highest in the history of baseball
Warren Spahn 1942-1965 Braves/Mets/Giants
13 seasons with 20 plus wins. 382 complete games with 363 wins. Most wins by a left-handed pitcher. Adjusted ERA 118
Christy Mathewson 1900-1916 Giants/Reds
373 Wins with a career 2.13 ERA. Adjusted ERA 135
Sandy Koufax 1955-1966 Dodgers
His dominance during the 1961-1966 seasons may never be matched again. The last 4 seasons of his career didn’t have a WHIP higher than 0.985 Won Cy Young Award and MVP in 1963 going 25-5 with a 1.88 ERA, Adjusted ERA 131
Tom Seaver 1967-1986 Mets/Reds/White Sox/Red Sox
311 Wins with a career 2.86 ERA, 3 Cy Young Awards, Adjusted ERA 127
Closer
Mariano Rivera 1995-present day Yankees
526 career saves and the most dominant ever to seal a victory. 10-time All-Star
Honorable Mention
Dennis Eckersley 1975-1998 Indians/Red Sox/ Cubs/ A’s/Cardinals
His dominance with the A’s changed the way the game was played. In 1992 won the Cy Young Award and MVP as a member of the A’s
Tags: Babe Ruth, Branch Rickey, Cy Young, Greg Maddux, Hank Aaron, Honus Wagner, Johnny Bench, Lefty Grove, Lou Gehrig, Mariano Rivera, Mike Schmidt, Randy Johnson, Rogers Hornsby, Ted Williams, Walter Johnson, Willie Mays
















By Ray Flowers on Mar 6, 2010
As great as Aaron was, I would remove him in favor of Cobb. Not only was Cobb voted greatest player alive, he also received a higher HOF vote than Babe Ruth in the same year of 1936 (98.2% to 95.1%).
Also, Cobb played in an era of no power which deflates his numbers. However, his adjusted OPS for his career if 168, the 10th best mark of all-time and well ahead of Aaron’s 155 mark despite the 600+ HR diff. between the two.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/onbase_plus_slugging_plus_career.shtml
By e papieros on Apr 14, 2010
I came across your site, i think your blog is cool, keep us posting.
By Free tattoo designs on Apr 14, 2010
Interesting article i totally agree with the comments above. Keep writing
By serwis motocykli Trojmiasto on May 21, 2010
You post informative articles. Bookmarked !